; ;

Binghamton Season Recap: Deadline Talent Dominates Second Half

By Jack Ramsey

September 25, 2026 No comments

Jonathan Santucci. Photo by Ed Delany of Metsmerized

The Binghamton Rumble Ponies played two completely different halves of a season in 2026. After finishing the first half with the worst record in the Eastern League, 15 games under .500, manager Michael Collins’ team surged to a .500 record in the second half, largely thanks to the talent the Mets brought in at the 2026 trade deadline.

The Binghamton first half was marked by injury and underperformance. Coming off a season in which he put up a .870 OPS with 17 homers, infielder Jacob Reimer struggled to stay on the field in the first half, posting a .643 OPS in April and appearing in only eight games in June. Reimer’s slow start was a microcosm of the larger issues for Binghamton as they struggled to get anything going in the first half.

The team scored just 283 runs in the first half, which came out to an average of just 4.1 runs per game. Their 283 runs scored were the lowest of any team in the Eastern League, and they were the only team to not cross the 300-run threshold. Their negative-52 run differential was the second worst of any team in the Eastern League, only to the Altoona Curve’s negative-68.

The league’s-worst offense mixed with a mediocre pitching staff was a recipe for disaster for Binghamton, but the impending sell-off by the major-league team at the 2026 trade deadline would end up being the source of great relief for the Rumble Ponies, and it was almost enough to propel them into the playoffs.

After finishing 28-43 in a disappointing first half, Binghamton was able to rally in the second half to the tune of a 34-34 record. Up in Queens, the Mets were selling off valuable deadline pieces leading up to the August 3rd deadline, and the Mets were able to bring in a new group of prospects to infuse into their farm system, with a great number of them heading to Binghamton.

Infielders Émilien Pitre, Billy Amick, and Jefferson Rojas were added to the heart of Collins’ lineup, starter Gary Gill Hill was added to the rotation, and pitcher Luke Gabrysh joined as well. Not only did the Mets add talent, but they added high-end talent with a top-100 prospect in Rojas, a potentially soon-to-be top-100 name in Pitre, and one of the most pure power bats in the minor leagues in Amick.

After the infusion of talent, the team ripped off a 34-32 run, a 17-game-over-.500 difference from how they ended their first half. It did not end up being enough to secure them a spot in the playoffs, as they did lose some of those key additions to Triplw-A Syracuse, but it showed the level of impact talent that the Mets were able to bring in.

Beyond the talent brought in at the trading deadline, the Ponies played host to a few incredible prospect developments this year, with perhaps none bigger than the trio of starter Jonathan Santucci and infielders Nick Lorusso, and Mitch Voit. Santucci would go on to lead the minor leagues in strikeouts this year, marking the second consecutive season that a Met took home that honor (Jonah Tong). In 19 Double-A starts before his promotion, the Duke product posted a 3.57 ERA with 120 strikeouts. Even though he authored just 90 innings, he finished in a tie for seventh in the league in strikeouts.

Lorusso’s professional career seemed to be on life support entering June, and he responded by posting a resounding 1.014 OPS with five homers in June and a .826 OPS with four homers in July. His positional versatility makes him an appealing prospect, as does the fact that he handled right-handed pitching significantly better than he did lefties, with a .795 OPS against righties and a .708 against lefties.

For Voit, he earned consecutive player of the week honors to bookend July and August, and would eventually be the Mets’ Player Development Player of the Year, thanks in large part to an explosion in the second half.

The 2025 first-round selection mashed over a 25-game stretch that began on July 24 with the High-A Brooklyn Cyclones and ended on August 30 with Binghamton, posting a 1.097 OPS with 12 doubles, two homers, a triple, and a slash-line of .401/.491/.606. Entering that stretch, the Michigan product had just a .738 OPS in the Southeastern Atlantic League.

Émilien Pitre. (Credits: MLB Pipeline on X)

Coaching Staff

Manager – Michael Collins

Bench Coach – Mariano Duncan

Hitting Coach – Rachel Folden

Assistant Hitting Coach – Jake Hager

Pitching Coach – Matt Carasiti

Athletic Trainer – Joe Parrillo

Performance Coach – Trent McMaster

Baseball Technology and Video Associate – Will Dolan

Clubhouse Manager – Mike Vavalle

Assistant Athletic Trainer – Emily French

Bullpen Catcher – Noah Fuller

MMO Top Prospects (Min. 30 GP/30 IP)

Team Batting Leaders

  • Games: C Chris Suero (114)
  • AB: C Chris Suero (403)
  • Runs: C Chris Suero (75)
  • Hits: C Chris Suero (81)
  • 2B: INF Jacob Reimer (21)
  • 3B: INF Marco Vargas (4)
  • HR: INF Nick Lorusso (19)
  • RBI: INF Nick Lorusso (55)
  • BB: C Chris Suero (80)
  • SO: C Chris Suero (145)
  • SB: C Chris Suero (37)
  • CS: C Chris Suero (9)
  • BA (Qualified): OF Jose Ramos (.218)
  • OBP (Qualified): C Chris Suero (.347)
  • SLG (Qualified): C Chris Suero (.395)
  • OPS (Qualified): C Chris Suero (.742)

Team Pitching Leaders

  • W: RHP Douglas Orellana (9)
  • L: RHP R.J. Gordon (7)
  • ERA (min. 60 IP): LHP Jonathan Santucci (3.57)
  • G: RHP Douglas Orellana (45)
  • GS: RHP R.J. Gordon (21)
  • SV: RHP Garrett Stratton (7)
  • IP: RHP Bryce Conley (93)
  • HR (allowed): RHP Bryce Conley (17)
  • BB: RHP Brendan Girton (57)
  • SO: LHP Jonathan Santucci (120)
  • WHIP (min. 60 IP): LHP Jonathan Santucci (1.25)
  • AVG (min. 30 IP): LHP Gabriel Rodriguez (.194)